Challenge, accepted! Hometown hero and self-proclaimed Bachelor enthusiast Jennifer Aniston stopped by Jimmy Kimmel Live on Thursday, where she was asked to share her selects for the final four contestants on Nick Viall’s upcoming season 21.
A longtime fan of the reality series, Aniston gladly narrowed down the list of 30 based on the girls’ photos, names, and occupations. After carefully gazing at a giant leaderboard of the contestants’ headshots, the actress went with Elizabeth for wearing “a good wedge!” in her pic, and Danielle, a neonatal nurse, whom the actress describes as “cute.”
Aniston also went with Corinne, a business owner, who was chosen, in part, thanks to her “beautiful blonde hair.” The star then took back her choice and commented, “She’s too young to get married.”
Rounding out the list was Rachel, because Aniston thought Viall might need the help of a lawyer. (The reason is not because of her beloved Friends character, Rachel Green.) “She’s an attorney. She’s smart,” the A-lister noted. “He’s going to need an attorney, don’t you think?”
The star, there to promote her new movie, Office Christmas Party, also hilariously called out the likely villain of the season based on her expression in her photo.
Aniston is actually real-life pals with Kimmel, who memorably officiated her wedding ceremony to Justin Theroux. The late-night host, who has been tasked with leading the Oscars in 2017, also helped throw Theroux’s bachelor party ahead of the couple’s nuptials.