There’s a lot of trouble ahead on Pretty Little Liars, especially after one character revealed on the Tuesday, July 5, episode that she’s secretly engaged. At the end of season 6, viewers already knew Toby Cavanaugh was planning to propose — but the question was, to whom?
His ex Spencer (Troian Bellisario) looked over Yvonne‘s (Kara Royster) file, thinking he had purchased an engagement ring for her. But the realization was made even worse when Spencer received a text from a mystery villain that read, “I guess she is better than you. He will never put a ring on your finger.” On Episode 3 of PLL, “The Talented Mr. Rollins,” that mystery was solved, though it wasn’t exactly the happiest news for one leading lady.
Spencer, who is on her way to help her ex Toby, bumps into his new fling, Yvonne. She tries to assure Toby’s girlfriend — RIP #Spoby — that her intentions are pure and she doesn’t want to cause any problems. (Side note: hello, she’s with Caleb now!) Yvonne, though, doesn’t buy Spencer’s comments and quickly retorts, “You already have.”
Just when the scene’s awkwardness reaches an all-time high, Yvonne blurts out to Spencer that she and Toby are already engaged. That ring he’d held onto since last season was put to good use, but not for Spencer as many of the fans would have hoped.
Upon hearing the news of Yvonne and Toby’s engagement, Spencer runs off to see her current boyfriend Caleb (Tyler Blackburn) to reassure herself that she still has some love in her life. Unfortunately, Spencer doesn’t necessarily get what she’s looking for. Caleb reveals he kissed his ex-girlfriend Hanna (Ashley Benson) and before he could confirm he still has feelings for Hanna (#Haleb forever) his phone rings.
Are Toby and Yvonne’s nuptials the big Pretty Little Liars wedding fans have been waiting for? Will Spencer finally find love in Caleb or a rekindled flame with Toby?
Catch the next episode of Pretty Little Liars on Freeform on Tuesday, July 12, at 8pm EST.